News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Trains meant for standing: official 

Trains meant for standing: official

7/10/2008 9:04:00 AM
V/LINE has rejected calls to control the number of passengers allowed on trains and says it is doing everything possible to cope with booming passenger numbers.

V/Line patronage increased 30 per cent in the 2006-07 financial year and 23 per cent in 2007-08.

Over the past few weeks The Advertiser has received several calls from disgruntled passengers standing on services from Melbourne to Bendigo, including one from regular traveller Megan Bowdell.

"I catch the train every second Sunday, usually the 5.15pm from Melbourne to Bendigo," she said.

"It's always packed - there are always people standing.

"It's a joke. It's ridiculous. There needs to be some control on how many people can get on."

V/Line spokesman Daniel Moloney said trains had been busy during school holidays and the AFL finals series.

Mr Moloney acknowledged the network was having "growing pains" in response to increased patronage.

"We are experiencing similar issues on the Geelong line," he said.

"Every line has three or four services that are consistently very busy.

"People often say 'just put on an extra carriage'.

"We would if we could, but they are in full use.''

The third new carriage of a scheduled 50 was delivered to the Gippsland line last week.

One has been allocated to the Bendigo line to deal with peak services.

Each month another carriage will be added to the V/Line fleet.

Mr Moloney said V/Line conductors would have the final say on passenger numbers for busier V/Line services.

"We're seeing huge numbers, and the nature of public transport is that we can't turn people back.

"The basic principle is that the conductors' discretion applies; they will make the decision about what they believe is acceptable."

He said that passengers were not being put at risk by standing.

"It is not a safety issue, it's a comfort issue - the trains are designed to allow people to stand.

"We don't want it to be that way, but the alternative is to deny people travel."

As a guide, a two-carriage VLocity train that seated 140 people could have 80 standing.

If the numbers standing exceeded this recommendation, passengers would be transported by coach.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
How come you have no report of the rail crossing fatal at Nelson Street, yesterday? ABC has a little detail on it, but not much...
Posted by MySay on 7/10/2008 7:33:21 AM
Please see page three of today's paper.

Peter Kennedy

Editor

Posted by Peter Kennedy on 7/10/2008 11:15:15 AM
I have been a passenger on many of V/Lines over crowded trains during both peak and off peak trains and I think it is appaling that nothing is being done to not only accomodate the large number of people who no longer can afford or want to drive to work/Uni etc. but to make our travels alot safer. At times the amount of people standing leaves the trains looking like a can of sardines and it is very hard to safely move from one spot to the other when getting on and off the trains. I have seen many elderly passengers trip over the legs and feet all over the walkways but experience EXTREME difficulties getting off/on the trains. Dont you think its already hard enough to move on a train let alone, with out adding the added carnage?? If a train were to be involved in a crash similar to the Kerang accident and there were people standing everywhere how may people do you think would survive!! I can imagine from the images of crashes similar to and of the Kerang crash and I think you would have a lot to answer for! You can afford to buy these so called fast trains that most of the time are not a great deal quicker, yet you cant afford to get a few carriages to improve our chances of a safer trip! Stop thinking about your pockets and think about the safety of the many loyal customers you have! And before it is too late! If it were a car being overloaded like trains do Im sure something would soon be done! GROW UP V/LINE
Posted by "STAND UP" for our safety! on 7/10/2008 4:27:49 PM
I have been on numerous services which are overcrowded. On one particular evening the 4.53 service did not run, and most of those people were not advised and were still waiting when the 5.00 left. They were forced onto the 5.37pm train. The 5.37 train had problems and was then reduced from a 4 carriage to 2 carriage train. And to make it worse the train didn't leave until about 6.20. Talk about packed! And contrary to Vline's claims that 'it's school holidays and AFL finals series' this was prior to that. I should also add that the VLine staff at Spencer Street Station also need to be mentioned for their consistentcy in providing really poor customer service. They fail to advise passengers of cancellations and changes to trains. When you ask, they treat you like it is such a bother to answer your request, or don't know the answer and can't be bothered finding out. And for VLine to make mention of coaches. What a joke! I have never seen a coach run because of cancellations or overcrowded services, but have seen plenty of times when it should have been used. Yes the trains may be designed to carry 80 passengers, but it is unrealistic to expect passengers to stand for over an hour (as does happen).
Posted by Disgruntled with crappy service on 9/10/2008 9:28:03 AM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

3/01/2009 | EARLIER this past week, jet setting celebrity Paris Hilton and her entourage dropped into Melbourne and among other things, splurged about $5000 in just under one hour at a trendy Chapel Street boutique.
Ron Poyser
 
Bendigo Access Employment
 
Innes Motors
 
Best Employment
 
MyCareer
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...